
Signature électronique vs manuscrite : le comparatif
Valeur juridique, rapidité, traçabilité, coût : comparaison honnête entre signature électronique et signature manuscrite papier.
Updated on the
Pasting the image of one's handwritten signature on a document is a common practice but its legal value is weak and easily disputed.
A scanned handwritten signature (or digitized signature ) is the image of your paper signature photographed or scanned that is inserted into a document, usually a PDF or Word file.
This is very different from an electronic signature within the meaning of the eIDAS Regulation, which is based on a technical process linking the signature to the signatory and ensuring the integrity of the document.
Under French law, electronic writing has the same evidentiary value as paper, provided that its author is reliably identified and the document is kept under conditions which guarantee its integrity (Article 1366 of the Civil Code).
A simple photo-paste does not satisfy either of these two conditions reliably: there is no proof that the person who signed it did so, and the image can be copied and reused on another document.
The electronic signature (eIDAS) exactly solves the weaknesses of the scanned signature: it links the signature to the signatory via authentication (OTP e-mail/SMS), seals the integrity of the document and produces a timestamped audit trail all of which can be challenged in court.
Depending on the challenge, the appropriate level is chosen: simple (SES), advanced (AES, the recommended standard) or qualified (QES, the legal equivalent of handwritten signature).
With Certyneo, you can replace the scanned image with a real electronic signature in minutes: import your PDF, place the signature fields, send the link to the signatories.
The signed document and its eIDAS evidence file are timestamped and archived, giving you robust evidence where the scanned signature left only a questionable image.
Sources and resources
It is not prohibited and may be used as a starting point for evidence, but its legal value is low: it does not guarantee the reliable identification of the signatory or the integrity of the document (Articles 1366 and 1367 of the Civil Code).
A scanned signature is a simple image pasted onto a document.An electronic signature (eIDAS) is a process that links the signature to the signer, ensures the integrity of the document and produces a much more evidence-based time-stamped audit trail.
It is acceptable as evidence, but its probative power is weak: in the event of a dispute, it is up to the person using it to prove its authenticity.
Yes. Instead of pasting an image, you import your document into Certyneo and have it signed electronically: the signer authenticates, the document is sealed and time stamped, and an eIDAS evidence file is generated.
Definition, operation and legal value: the complete guide to get started.
Read the guideSES, AES, QES: the three levels of signature and the European framework.
Read the guideCompare the levels and choose the appropriate signature for each document.
Read the guideWe use cookies to improve your experience on our site. Cookies strictly necessary for the service to function are always active. Learn more about our cookie policy